Amber benson adam busch dating
This line of paleobiological thinking obviates ideas on a proclaimed recent origin of the flower (Glover et al. A 100 million year old eudicot flower unearthed from the North American Lower Cretaceous Dakota Formation is pictured on the right-hand side of the page. The fossil record of flowering plants is grossly incomplete despite an optimistic appraisal by Friis et al. Every one of the simulations computed by Beaulieu et al. and challenge the hypothesis that these two orders diversified contemporaneously with angiosperms" (quoted from K. Possible nectar secretions of Cascolaurus burmitis (Lauraceae, Magnolianae) are entombed in 100 million year-old Myanmar amber (Poinar 2017). The eukaryotic tool kit is the biochemical machinery necessary to orchestrate the development of living bodies, which involves interacting genes, hormones, and cis-acting transcription factors (TFs), among other molecules of cells, tissues, and organs. Further, molecular-phylogenetic studies of homeodomain proteins and TFs posit deep conservation of cone and floral CRMs, GRNs, efflux carriers, and auxin-based polarity networks (PINs). 2011, Feild and Brodribb 2013, Zwieniecki and Boyce 2014, and Lee et al. Feild and Arens (2007) are probably standing on thin ice when asserting that flowering plants originated in specific terrestrial paleoenvironments during the earliest Cretaceous Period. 2017), and APG IV (2016) might be unhelpful in understanding the angiosperm floral paradox. The drawing to the right is Euanthus panii (family uncertain, order not yet assigned, Magnolianae). (2017) suggest that the holotype of Euanthus panii is a fragmented conifer cone. (2017) when considered together with the anatomy of the conifer cone axis, casts a shadow over Zhong-Jian Liu and Xin Wang's interpretation of Euanthus panii. (2017) review of the fossil history of flowering plants presents cogent arguments casting doubt on most claims of pre-Cretaceous angiosperm fossils. Simply put, Sanmiguelia lewisii might represent surviving populations of Vojnovskya paradoxa that survived the PT as part of a plexus of monocotyledonous stem-group flowering plants in early Triassic times and places. Are certain homologies of reproductive organs of Caytonia proposed by J. 2013) paleobotanists may wish to reconsider homologies of angiosperm and ginkgoalean integuments. a strong level of [MADS-box B sister] expression was maintained throughout the ovule [of Ginkgo biloba] also in later stages of development, when a layered organization of the integument had clearly developed, and both the inner and the outer integuments could be distinguished [Fig. Figure 2 and page 774 (Pott 2016) showing Pterophyllum filicoides foliage and associated Westersheimia pramelreuthensis ovules, is instructive. clearly indicate that early [Carnian - Upper Triassic] bennettitalean seeds can be interpreted as unitegmic" (proper nouns [in brackets] are mine). Monocots are in various shades of green or orange (Alismatidae are denoted by blue-green type, Arecidae with yellow type, Zingiberidae are shown in gold letters, Commelinidae have green letters, and Liliidae are depicted in lime green type). These palynomorphs may represent the first Mesozoic records of stem group angiosperms, but whole plant fossils are lacking (Friis et al. Yet another important study of pollen samples recovered from isolated sedimentary layers in (at least one) continuous stratigraphic sequence in two deep well cores, reports monosulcate, columellate palynomorphs, and Afropollis, from the Middle Triassic (Anisian) about 240 MYA (Hochuli and Feist-Burkhardt 2013). I completely reject the assertion by some workers that angiosperms first appeared in the Cretaceous Period (Feild and Arens 2007). "Angiosperm phylogeny is riddled with examples of convergent morphologies ...
Further, there is simply no evidence of a transitional series or chronocline leading from Caytoniales and Doyleales to the Amborellanae, Austrobaileyanae, Nymphaeanae, and Magnolianae. When defined on a foundation of morphology and evolutionary-development (evo-devo) of the molecular tool kit, the angiosperm flower becomes a deeply-conserved organ with a body plan seen in several Paleozoic seed plant fossils including species of Vojnovskyales, among others yet to be confirmed by sophisticated paleobotanical studies. imply that the diversification that lead to living angiosperm species began sometime between the Upper Triassic and the early Permian." Rate Scenario 3 depicted in Figure 4 on page 874 of Beaulieu et al. Students have ample opportunities to compare and contrast Bayesian relaxed-clock methods and to discuss Yule birth-death priors when comparing angiosperm and seed plant phylogenies computed by Bell et al. Based on gene expression studies of extant angiosperm species does the foliar morphology, stem anatomy, and growth habit of Sanmiguelia lewisii display the fingerprint of an "ancestral developmental tool kit" (title, Floyd and Bowman 2007) of a monocotyledonous flowering plant? Definitive paleontological evidence published by Peter Hochuli and Susanne Feist-Burkhardt should be read together with a 2013 Sidney Ash and Hasiotis review of Sanmiguelia paleobiology, and their report of three new localities from the Blue Mesa Member (Norian) of the Lower Triassic Chinle Formation of southwestern North America. (2014) suggest Early Cretaceous "spectacular diversifications" of ants, bees, butterflies, moths, flies, and wasps with "the radiation of flowering plants." Yet, there are incongruencies in a milestone phylogenomic analysis of 1468 single-copy insect nuclear genes by the Bernhard Misof team (2014) with reanalyses of the data by K. (2015) employing Bayesian priors and fine-tuning node calibrations with fossils, which parallel problems with competing analyses of seed plant molecular data sets discussed by Beaulieu et al. These are ≈100 My [million years] earlier than those of Misof et al. Our estimates are consistent with the fossil record ... There is ample paleobiological evidence of early flowering plants interacting with insects (Labandeira 2014). Primer on Developmental Tool Kits: Many of the links on this web site lead to educational material having to do with the developmental tool kit. "By considering entire GRNs involved in key developmental processes and investigating changes in entire GRNs across evolutionary lineages researchers can begin to piece together the fundamental genetic and genomic principles underlying the conservation and evolution of form." The previous statement is quoted from the concluding section eight on page 87 of C. Fertile spur shoots are demonstrably ancient organs known from Permo-carboniferous seed plant fossils. Stem Group Flowering Plants: Unequivocal stem group angiosperms remain unknown (D. There is considerable discussion in the scientific literature on flowering plant foliar physiology and water relations needed to explain ecological success of angiosperms (Feild and Arens 2007, Feild et al. angiosperms represent the only clade that evolved a xylem conduit anatomy sufficiently conductive to permit miniature vessels to maintain water supply" (page 723, Feild and Brodribb 2013). I discuss this discovery among others from the Xin Wang Laboratory and Nanjing Institute of Geology and Palaeontology elsewhere on this web site. Doyle's opinions on the evolutionary relationships of Sanmiguelia lewisii with monocotyledonous flowering plants. Based on Figure 10 (Rothwell and Stockey 2016), species of Mesozoic Doyleales did not. Late in 2016 a study of detached and shed bennettitalean ovules and seeds was published by Christian Pott, which adds to a growing body of evidence that pteridosperm cupules had nothing to do with evolution of anthophyte integuments. More paleontological data are critically needed in line with suggestions by E. Douglas Soltis and co-workers offer one of several updates of the ongoing research effort to compute the angiosperm tree of life from molecular data (D. The color of typescript in the remainder of figures on this web page allows visual cross reference to subclasses of flowering plants (Cronquist 1981) where a discussion of characters is available. Dilleniidae appear on the dendrogram labels in royal blue. Rosidae are colored red and Asteridae appear in black type. Fossilized pollen casings known as palynomorphs are known from middle Triassic sediments recovered from deep well bore holes drilled off the island of Spitzbergen (Hochuli and Feist-Burkhardt 2004). (2009) are more complete and detailed than my brief summary (Tables 5-12).
The classification proposed by Chase and Reveal (2009) for angiosperms is accompanied by a scheme for extant gymnosperms, which is published by Christenhusz et al. Certain ANITA grade basal flowering plants first appear in the fossil record of the Cretaceous Period (Friis et al. 2001, Krassilov and Golovneva 2004, Takahashi et al.
A summary of results of analyses depicted in Figures 3-5 on pages 345-346 of C. This inferred age is at least ≈50 myr, and up to ≈110 myr, older than the oldest known fossils attributed to crown-group angiosperms" (page 349, Conclusions, C. Existence of dilleniid Javelinoxylon trees belonging to derived crown group eudicots as an important floristic element of late Cretaceous stratified tropical forests of southwestern North America (Wheeler and Lehman 2000), and large trees of Paraphyllanthoxylon indigenous to European forests of that time (Oakley and Falcon-Lang 2009), detract from the idea that early flowering plants were paleoherbs of upland habitats. Chloranthales are unplaced (Chase and Reveal 2009).
Vamosi 2010), or diversification was affected by escalation (Vermeij 2011).
(2015), yield results concordant with Zhenxiang Xi et al. (2014) are the first to resolve an Amborella Nuphar phylogenetic couplet as sister to all other extant angiosperms when coalescent techniques are employed in computation, simulations, and tree-thinking. Our results lend further empirical support for analyzing genome-scale data to resolve deep phylogenetic relationships using coalescent methods, and provide the most convincing evidence to date that Amborella plus Nymphaeales together represent the earliest diverging lineage of extant angiosperms" (page 929, Results and Discussion, Accommodating Elevated Rates of Substitution in Coalescent versus Concatenation Analyses, Xi et al. A review and phylogenetic analysis incorporates early Cretaceous fossil data with input from extant basal angiosperms and magnoliids (J. Certain other Magnoliales once regarded by Cronquist (1981) as primitive angiosperms (Annonaceae, Degeneriaceae, Lactoridaceae, Magnoliaceae, Myristicaceae, Trimeniaceae, and Winteraceae) are in a more derived position on phylogenetic trees based on molecular data (Wikström et al.
Two books dealing with the subject of angiosperm evolution and paleofloristics (Dilcher 2010, Friis et al. Dispersal of these floras from the tropics poleward has been proposed (Axelrod 1959). (2005) suggesting a monophyletic Mesozoic origin of a basal clade of flowering plants, which is based on estimates derived from cp DNA data. I also built a case and presented evidence in the second essay that some of the candidate gymnosperm groups with bisexual protoflowers are presently known only from detached taeniopteroid sporophylls and foliar tepals of Ginkgo-like spur shoots, and subtending gigantopteroid megaphylls. These studies are congruent with Bayesian molecular-clock simulations computed by Beaulieu et al. " (Abstract Scope and Conclusions, page 145, Becker 2016, item [in brackets] is mine). After integrating evidence as a whole with our results, the resulting scenario suggests that there is nothing particularly mysterious about the diversification of angiosperms during Cretaceous times or how it is reflected in the fossil record. Does this overlooked and thoughtful comparison merit further exploration? "The male structures [of Sanmiguelia] appear to be strobili with sessile pairs of pollen sacs, more reminiscent of ginkgophytes than angiosperms, and the smooth monosulcate pollen has no angiosperm features" (page 319, J. Sanmiguelia lewisii was an innovative Triassic plant having palm-like leaves (Brown 1956, Ash 1976) with flowers and angiosperm-like reproductive modules not unlike the monocotyledonous angiosperm Veratrum (Cornet 1986, 1989). This is an unstudied chronocline with potentially profound implications toward the idea of paraphyletic transitions in diverging seed plants at the base of the angiosperm stem(s) that straddle the PT. Triassic angiosperm fossils of detached "dicot-like" leaves described as Pannaulika triassica are known (Cornet 1993). Fossils of several other enigmatic flowering plants have been recovered from Mesozoic rocks but reproductive details and the morphology of whole plants are unclear due to problems with poor preservation and uncertain stratigraphic control (Müller 1981, G. There is a significant increase in the number of orders and genera of fossil flowering plants by the Aptian Age of the Gallic Epoch of the Cretaceous Period, based on data in Table 5.
Specimen IU15713-3429 was first photographed by the author in 1981 with the permission of Professor David L. The same specimen was illustrated in Figure 1 [as "D"] on Page 512 of J. A Mesozoic radiation of angiosperms is cast within the framework of the Angiosperm Phylogeny Group proposed classification (APG III 2009, Chase and Reveal 2009, APG IV 2016). (B) Superposition with the homeodomain of Drosophila engrailed bound to DNA [yellow, PBD-id: 1hdd], where the centre of recognition helix α3 inserts into the major groove." Reprinted by permission from Macmillan Publishers Ltd: The European Molecular Biology Organization (EMBO) Journal, Hamès, C., D. A possible paraphyletic Paleozoic origin of angiosperms is incongruent with proposals by Leebens-Mack et al. Ancestors of putative paraphyletic grades of angiosperms might have been Permo-carboniferous or Permo-triassic gymnosperms with hermaphroditic (bisexual) strobili. 2008) suggests deep conservation of the developmental tool kit of vascular plants. "While the amazing conservation of the major floral identity [ABCDE] program is being unravelled by analysing floral homeotic gene function and expression, we are only just beginning to understand the evolution of the gene network governing the organ identity genes ... cit.) should understand that petriellalean cupules are incompatible with tool kit models of floral development from shoot apical meristems (SAMs). We anticipate that the evident question-whether beyond the mere ecological similarity there may be phylogenetic relationships linking Petriellales with angiosperms-will be answered once more detailed information about their reproductive biology becomes available" (page 1074, Discussion, Ecology and Paleoenvironment, Bomfleur et al. Caytoniales, Corystospermales, Doyleales, and Petriellales probably had nothing to do with the evolution of stem-group flowering plants or the origin of angiosperms. Is the bitegmic ovule an angiosperm-specific character? Conversely, can ategmic ovules develop by fusion of integuments? fossil-based, molecular, phylogenetic and paleobiogeographic studies) and current viewpoints about the explosive Cretaceous diversification of angiosperms. Of all the enigmatic seed plants of the early Mesozoic Era, Sanmiguelia lewisii has attracted the most attention by students of angiosperm paleobiology (S. Crane (1985) suggested that some populations of late Paleozoic Vojnovskyales might have survived the end-Permian extinction reappearing in the Triassic rock record as the seed plant Sanmiguelia. The problem is also semantic as expressed in conflicting opinions on the definition of angiosperms, flowers, and from opposing ideas on supposed character homologies with organs of Paleozoic seed plants. Doyle's earlier critique of Cornet's published studies of the morphology and anatomy of Sanmiguelia lewisii, before publishing the Nature Plants "palaeobotanical redux." Uncanny similarities of early Mesozoic seed plant Sanmiguelia lewisii (Cornet 1986, 1989) with Paleozoic Vojnovskyales pointed out by Crane (1985) require confirmation by phylogenetic analysis of reproductive and vegetative characters gleaned from detailed anatomical studies of more fossilized remains to be collected. The Archaemagnoliidae is lumped with the Magnoliidae. Molecular-phylogenetic studies suggest that differentiation of flowering plants into a stem and crown group of the Mesozoic Era is feasible (Hilu et al.
(2016), Rothwell and Stockey (2016) and Rothwell et al. The rock contains an indeterminate eudicot fossil flower, which is the same "Rose Creek Flower" discussed by Friis et al. Dilcher (1984), Ancient bisexual flowers, Science 224: 511-513. (2008), "Comparison of LFY-C with paired and homeodomain DNA binding. "Did insect pollination cause increased seed plant diversity? These questions, among others (Berendse and Scheffer 2009, Crepet and Niklas 2009) should now be discussed from a late Paleozoic temporal perspective based on evidence presented in the first and second essays. There is growing consensus among some molecular systematists and paleobotanists on the existence of a 160 million year old angiosperm ghost lineage rooted at the angiosperm-gymnosperm split roughly 300 MYA, prior to the end-Permian extinction. Vivian Irish (2006) provides a road map to diversification of the angiosperm clade from the perspective of evo-devo of floral homeotic genes, their phenotypic expression, and molecular phylogenies. Specifically, our results indicate that the heterodimerization between DEF-like and GLO-like proteins was already present in the [most common recent ancestor] MRCA of extant angiosperms and was virtually never rewired" (page 1438, Discussion, Conservation of the MADS-domain protein interaction pattern during angiosperm evolution, Melzer et al. Most of the explosive radiation of floral diversity in basal lineages of flowering plants is explained by duplication and diversification of the MIKC-type MADS-box family of genes (P. The reconstructed physiology and ecology of the Petriellales matches this life form to such detail that we suggest these unusual gymnosperms may represent convergent ecological analogues of early flowering plants" (page 1074, Discussion, Ecology and Paleoenvironment, Bomfleur et al. Taking into account the morphology of reproductive short shoots of Winteraceae (i.e. Hochuli, Palaeontological Institute and Museum, University of Zürich, Zürich, Switzerland. I did not include numerous reports and descriptions of Mesozoic leaf morphotype genera (Dilcher and Basson 1990, Upchurch and Dilcher 1990, among others) to avoid guesswork on their taxonomic placement without benefit of reproductive structures. The number of extant genera (in parentheses) in the table below was compiled from Cronquist's family descriptions (1981).
Further, the elaborate analyses published by Goremykin et al. regardless of whether Amborella alone is the sister to all other extant angiosperms or whether Amborella Nymphaeales form a clade, one cannot infer the habit or habitat of the first angiosperms based on the morphology of extant taxa" (page 379, Discussion, Drew et al. The genome-scale molecular phylogenetic analyses by Zhenxiang Xi et al. Basal flowering plants sensu Cronquist (1981) belong to Amborellaceae and Trimeniaceae (Laurales), Austrobaileyaceae (Magnoliales), Hydatellales (monocots), Illiciales, and Nymphaeales.
Tremendous progress has been made on understanding the anatomy, basic biology, organelle genetics, developmental genetics, ecology, floral genetics, molecular evolution, morphology, natural history, and phylogenetic systematics of ANITA grade basal angiosperms (Parkinson et al.
Was Triassic Pangaea a "world devoid of angiosperms" (page 295, Conclusions, Labandeira 2014). Studies of the "angiosperm history" and the genome landscape of the poster-boy (-girl) basal angiosperm Amborella trichopoda (Amborellaceae, Amborellales, Amborellanae) are probably unhelpful in deciphering the paleobiology of Permo-carboniferous seed plant groups modeled by Jiao et al. From an evo-devo research perspective with focus on biochemical and gene expression studies of CRMs, GRNs, PINs, and cis-acting TFs, and underlying mechanisms involving homeodomain proteins and auxin-based polarity networks (Becker 2016), the angiosperm flower with its nested structures and reproductive modules is a deeply-conserved seed plant organ. and its initial evolutionary modifications ..." within the context of extant basal angiosperms, Endress and J. Doyle (2009) state: The preceding two quotations are from page 23 of P. Scanning electron micrographs were prepared by Al Soeldner, Director, Oregon State University Electron Microscopy Laboratory. Some clues from combined morphological- and molecular-phylogenetic analyses are reviewed by these authors, which are distilled in the bulleted list below: Additional clues may be gleaned from field- and greenhouse-studies of floral genetics in Amborella trichopoda by Anger et al. The breeding system in the Mont Aoupinié stand of Amborella trichopoda is plastic (Anger et al. Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences 40: 301326. A permineralized compound cone recovered from a concretion found in a North American Valanginian rock outcrop on Vancouver Island yielded a surprising trove of cupules, ovules, axillary shoots, bracts, and megasporophylls (right-hand image) attached to a mostly complete female cone axis (Rothwell and Stockey 2016). Principal references on angiosperm classification and floristics are Engler (1964), Thorne (1968), Dahlgren (1980), Cronquist (1981), Dahlgren and Clifford (1982), Dahlgren et al. Cladistics is a scientific tool with mathematical and theoretical limitations (Graur and Martin 2004) that should not be a final determinant of classification (Stuessy 2009).
2015) including monocotyledonous flowering plants (Eguchi and Tamura 2016). Müller (2008), Structural basis for LEAFY floral switch function and similarity with helix-turn-helix proteins. The Apterous (ap) compartment selector gene encodes Apterous protein, which is another TF involved in subdivision of imaginal discs into dorsal and ventral compartments of developing fruit flies (S. Tool kit studies might help paleobiologists decipher cone and floral novelties and illuminate ecologies of insect mutualisms in extinct, hybridizing seed plant populations. Doyle (2009), Hileman and Irish (2009), Rasmussen et al. While discussing their perception of the flower "... Students should compare this scanning electron micrograph with the sample prepared by Peter Endress (page 563, Figure 21, 2015). A somewhat different picture is painted by Bernhardt (page 313, 2000) who suggested that "labile sexuality is ancestral to the angiosperms." Based on mounting evo-devo, morphological, and paleobotanical evidence, the floral bauplan is probably considerably more ancient than generally thought by Chanderbali et al. "Some authors seem curiously determined to prove that pre-Cretaceous fossils are crown-group angiosperms, but for understanding most aspects of the origin of angiosperms [other than their age], close stem relatives would be far more significant ..." The preceding statement is quoted from page 318 of J. Doyle (2012), Molecular and fossil evidence on the origin of angiosperms. Classification levels of order and genus are used in the tabulations below because the number of genera in extant floras is the most commonly used biogeographically significant measure of biodiversity.